Chapter 15: Having Second Thoughts

Chapter Fifteen: Having second Thoughts
Arnold's POV
"Me too." I grind my hard-on against his stiff cock. "Mutual lust." I kiss him again, then pull away and get on my hands and knees. "I'll do more than your college guy. I've kissed you, sucked your cock, and fucked your ass . . ." I wave my butt seductively. "
"Now, I want you to fuck me." I grin, even though he can't see it. "I'll bet my asshole's tighter than his, too."
"Well, let's find out." He moves behind me and picks the lube up. I wait, horny but scared. His dick looks awfully big for my tight little ass.
My cock jerks as Logan slips a lubricated finger up my butthole. It's startling, but doesn't hurt. "Yep," he says. "It's pretty tight." He works his finger in my butt, occasionally pulling it out to add more lube. My painfully hard dick throbs and my balls tighten, but after coming twice in the past few minutes, I'm not close to shooting.
"You like that?" Logan asks, fingering me roughly.
"Sure." I'm still scared, but I want Logan's giant pole up my ass more than anything .
"Good." He pulls his finger out of my butt.
"Then, you'll like THIS even more." His cock-head presses into my anus. It feels weird, but doesn't really hurt. I'm thinking this is going to be easy. Then, it does hurt, a sharp stab of pain from my overstretched anal muscles.
I gasp and try to pull away. Logan grips my waist to hold me in place. "It's okay." He pulls back slightly.
"I'll take it easy."
He stays still for a few seconds and then pushes forward, opening my super-tense anal ring a little wider. It hurts when he goes too far, but this time I'm expecting the pain. My body stiffens, but I don't try to jerk away.
Like before, Logan stops pushing and then pulls back. "Beat off," he says. "It helps." I grab my stiff rod and stroke it roughly as Logan works his cock-head deeper into my overstretched anus.
I scream as his broad plow-head slips through my tight anal ring and his long thick cock slides smoothly up my ass. My cock throbs and it feels like I'm coming, although I don't actually shoot. It hurts, a little, but also sends a wave of overpowering pleasure surging through my body.
"You all right?" Logan slowly draws back and then pushes back into my butt, just as slowly. His balls press against my butt cheeks. His big cock is all the way up my asshole.
"I'm great." I tighten my anal muscles, clamping Logan's big rod. "I've never felt anything this good." I rock my hips, moving his rigid pole in and out of my butt.
"Fuck me. Good and hard. I'm ready for you."
Logan fucks me like a horny teenage boy—hard and fast, with seemingly limitless energy. I thrust backward to meet his driving rod, slamming my buttocks into his crotch and taking his long thick pole even deeper.
I reach for my throbbing dick, but then stop. I'm on my hands and knees right over the still-slick streak of cum Logan spewed on the sheets while I was fucking him. I sink onto the bed. Logan lies on top of me, pressing my body into the mattress.
"That's right!" I gasp. "Fuck me!" I hump the sheets, sliding my stiff pole over the slick puddle of Logan's cum while his hard hot rod hammers my ass. The tension in my straining nuts builds .
"Oh yeah!" Logan growls. "I'm fucking your hot tight ass." He slams into my butt, shaking the bed under me. We've both come twice in the last few minutes, but I know he's ready again. Just like I am.
"Come on!" I cry. "Shoot it! Shoot your big—" A hot hard jet of cum splashes my anal walls. That sets me off and my throbbing pole squirts more cum onto the slick sheets.
Logan pounds my ass, shooting over and over. I keep coming, too, adding more cum to the big puddle on the sheets under me.
We finally finished. Logan pulls his dick out of my butt and we cuddle at the edge of the bed, avoiding the big wet spot in the center.
"That was great," I say. "I was horny as hell but scared to death. Your cock was so big . . . But, you knew just how to handle a scared virgin."
Logan frowns, like he's deciding if he should answer. "Well . . . Big Bro's buddy kinda taught me."
"He fucked your ass?"
"Yeah. He gave me another beer and we smoked a joint. I'd fucked his ass and he said, 'Fair is fair.' I couldn't really argue with that . . ."
"I guess not." I kiss Logan. "He taught you well."
We turn out the light and fall asleep after that. In the morning, we take a shower together. We spend a lot more time playing with each other's cocks and asses than in getting clean.
We get out of the shower, dripping wet. Logan bends me over the counter and fucks me from behind while I watch him in the mirror. Then, I fuck him. After that, we finish the shower quickly, because the hot water running out.
Logan strips the bed before we go upstairs. He does the laundry, so he's not worried about his parents seeing the cum stains.
We kiss passionately at the foot of the stairs. We've both got jobs, so we won't have many chances to see each other this summer. But, we're going to the same college this fall. Maybe we can be roommates . . .
* * * * * Throwback Ends * * * * *
He was at the door all through it, I took the risk to send him the address but never knew or thought that he would come or agree to the group! And he did making me.feel all flustered about the details I let out and at the same time horny secretly hoping that it left him as breathless as I.
I'm always threading with caution when it comes to my latest crush, this might just be a phase and I can't share him if happens to be bi.