Chapter 80: Phantom Shadows(2)
The plan came together with surprising speed, drawing on each of our particular skills. Braden's methodical organization, Ryan's technical expertise, my theatrical sensibilities, and Nadia's intuitive understanding of human motivation.
"Whoever sent this letter has been watching me perform," she reasoned as we gathered around the dining table. "They'll continue watching. Which means they'll notice if something changes in my preparation routine."
"We create a situation they can't resist investigating," I contributed, understanding her direction immediately.
"Exactly." She leaned forward, energy radiating from her. "We let it be known that I'm seriously considering their offer. That I'm practicing opera repertoire instead of Phantom music."
"How would they know that?" Ryan asked skeptically.
"Because I'll practice with the windows open," she explained. "I'll take specific scores to the theater, leave them visible in my dressing room. I'll mention it to people—that I received a mysterious opportunity that might be even better than The Phantom."
"Gossip spreads quickly in theater circles," I confirmed, appreciating the elegant simplicity of the approach. "Especially something this intriguing."
"Meanwhile," she continued, "Ryan sets up surveillance. Not just on the brownstone, but on me. We need to know who's watching."
Ryan nodded slowly, professional challenges engaging his problem-solving instincts. "I can rig cameras at key locations. Nothing obvious, but effective. The theater, the routes you typically walk, the coffee shop you frequent."
"And I'll help craft the perfect operatic repertoire," I volunteered, theatrical instincts fully engaged. "Something that suggests you're taking this seriously, but still deciding. We need to create the impression of genuine consideration, not obvious bait."
"I can contact some actual opera coaches," Braden suggested. "Make it authentic. If someone's been watching closely enough to assess your technique, they'll know if you're merely pretending."
Nadia's eyes lit with appreciation. "Yes. Perfect."
"What's perfect?" Andy's voice came from the doorway. He'd returned from his meeting, surveying our impromptu war council with quiet curiosity.
Ryan quickly brought him up to speed, showing him the letter and outlining our developing plan. Andy listened without interruption, his expression thoughtful.
"May I see the envelope again?" he requested when Ryan finished.
Ryan handed it over, and Andy examined it with careful attention, turning it over in his hands with methodical precision. "This was unsealed when delivered," he said finally.
"How can you tell?" I asked, impressed despite myself.
"The adhesive strip has been reactivated," he explained, holding it toward the light to demonstrate. "See how the pattern is disrupted? Someone opened it, then resealed it before delivery."
"Why would they do that?" Nadia wondered.
"To make sure the contents were correct?" Braden suggested.
"Or to add something," Andy countered quietly.
A chill ran through the room at his implication. Ryan immediately took the letter from Nadia's hand, holding it up to the light as Andy had demonstrated with the envelope.
"There's something here," he confirmed, voice tight with suppressed anger. "Extremely fine particles embedded in the paper. Not visible to the naked eye, but they catch the light at certain angles."
"What kind of particles?" Braden asked, expression darkening.
Ryan shook his head. "Could be anything. Tracking powder. Chemical residue."
"You think someone's trying to track Nadia?" I asked, theatrical imagination immediately constructing dramatic scenarios.
"I think we don't know what we're dealing with," Ryan replied grimly. "And until we do, we need to be extremely careful."
The mood in the room shifted from determined to somber. What had seemed an unusual but potentially innocent professional approach now carried darker implications.
"I still want to proceed with the plan," Nadia declared, her voice steady despite the concern evident in her eyes. "But with adjustments. If someone's watching this closely, let's use it. Let's make them reveal themselves."
"It's risky," Braden cautioned.
"Everything worthwhile involves risk," she countered. "Besides, now that we know, we have the advantage."
I watched her with newfound appreciation. The Nadia who had first entered our household—uncertain, eager to please, grateful for opportunity—had evolved into something formidable. She balanced vulnerability with strength, openness with strategic thinking.
"We'll need to coordinate precisely," Andy said, surprising us by engaging with the plan rather than urging caution. "Establish clear signals, emergency protocols, constant awareness of surroundings."
"We can do that," Ryan agreed, professional challenges engaging his problem-solving mind.
"And we still need to prepare for the actual audition," I reminded everyone. "Whatever else is happening, London remains our primary objective."
Nadia nodded, determination hardening her expression. "We solve this mystery, neutralize whatever threat it represents, then proceed to London as planned. All of us together."
"All of us," Braden echoed, though his gaze flickered briefly to Andy, acknowledging the unresolved complication of our fifth member's position.
As we refined the details of our plan, I found myself watching Nadia with new perspective. In our complex arrangement, she had always been the connecting element, the central node around which the rest of us orbited. But now I recognized something I'd underestimated—her capacity not just for receiving attention but for directing it. For turning observation into opportunity. For transforming threat into advantage.
Whoever this mysterious admirer was, they had fundamentally misunderstood who they were dealing with. They saw technical potential and artistic promise. They didn't see the woman who had navigated the perilous waters of our unconventional arrangement with grace and determination. They didn't see the survivor who had transformed disaster in The Proposition into triumph.
They didn't see Nadia completely. But they would. Soon enough.
And when they did, I almost pitied them. Almost.
The following morning, our plan launched with theatrical precision. Nadia began practicing Puccini arias with the library windows open, her voice carrying into the street below. I coached her with deliberate volume, emphasizing elements that would suggest serious classical training.
"More space in the soft palate on that high note," I instructed loud enough to be heard by anyone listening closely. "The Royal Opera expects absolute technical precision in the bel canto tradition."
Ryan had installed discreet surveillance equipment at key locations—the brownstone's exterior, Nadia's most frequent walking routes, the stage door of the Vandercant Theater. Andy had meticulously analyzed the letter and envelope for additional clues, creating a detailed profile of the paper type, ink composition, and handwriting characteristics.
Braden, meanwhile, made several ostentatious phone calls from the front steps, discussing opera coaches and Royal Opera scheduling with exaggerated concern for Nadia's conflicting opportunities.
"Yes, of course the Phantom audition remains scheduled," he said into his phone, voice carrying clearly to anyone who might be observing. "But given this unexpected development with the Royal Opera, we need to explore all options."
By afternoon, Nadia visited the theater for a scheduled costume fitting, conspicuously carrying scores for La Bohème and Madama Butterfly rather than her usual Phantom materials. She engaged the costume designer in animated conversation about the comparative challenges of opera versus musical theater, ensuring the information would circulate backstage.
"It's strange," she confided loudly to the sympathetic seamstress. "I've been focused on Christine for so long, and suddenly this mysterious opera opportunity appears. It's as if someone has been watching my entire career, waiting for the right moment to intervene."
Throughout the day, Ryan monitored the surveillance feeds, looking for repeated appearances, unusual attention, anyone lingering too long in Nadia's vicinity. Andy systematically contacted paper suppliers, tracking the distinctive stationery to its source. Braden and I maintained our visible support of Nadia's "consideration" of the operatic path, while continuing to prepare her for the actual Phantom audition during private sessions with doors closed and music subdued.
That evening, as we gathered to review the day's observations, an unexpected development emerged from Andy's methodical investigation.
"The paper was purchased three weeks ago from an exclusive stationer in Manhattan," he reported. "Imported Italian stock, sold in limited quantities to select customers."
"Can you get customer information?" Ryan asked eagerly.
"Not directly," Andy admitted. "But I've identified only seven potential purchasers based on timing and quantity. Three corporations, four individuals."
He displayed a list of names, none immediately recognizable except one—Elise Michaels, the production manager Ryan had interviewed with for the Hamilton European tour.
"This can't be coincidence," Ryan said, staring at the name.
"Why would the Hamilton production manager try to lure Nadia to the Royal Opera?" I questioned skeptically. "It makes no sense."
"Unless the Hamilton interview was a pretense," Braden suggested thoughtfully. "A way to gain information about our household. About our London plans."
The possibility settled uncomfortably in the room. Had Ryan's opportunity been nothing but elaborate reconnaissance? Had we revealed our personal dynamics, our collective ambitions, our vulnerabilities to someone with ulterior motives?
"I need to call Charlie," Ryan decided, pulling out his phone. "Find out how well he actually knows Elise Michaels."
As he stepped out to make the call, Nadia's phone chimed with a text notification. She checked it, her expression transforming from curiosity to focused intensity.
"Another message," she explained, holding up the phone for us to see. "Anonymous, sent from a blocked number."
The message was brief but compelling:
Your consideration of the Royal Opera opportunity has been noted with approval. To discuss details directly, come to the reflecting pool at Lincoln Center tomorrow at 11 AM. Come alone. This is a legitimate artistic opportunity, not a threat. Trust your instincts, not those who would limit your potential.
"It's happening faster than we anticipated," Braden observed, reading over her shoulder.
"They're monitoring more closely than we realized," I added, theatrical instincts constructing scenarios. "They noticed our activities immediately and responded."
"It's a trap," Ryan declared, returning from his call with grim certainty. "Charlie had never heard of Elise Michaels before she contacted him about interviewing me. She approached him, not the other way around, claiming to represent Hamilton's European tour."
"So the entire interview was fabricated?" I asked, struggling to process the implications. "Your London opportunity was never real?"
The devastating possibility hung in the air—not just for Ryan personally, but for our collective plans. If Ryan's European tour was fictional, our carefully constructed vision of maintaining connections across the ocean collapsed.
"I don't know," Ryan admitted, frustration evident in his voice. "The interview felt legitimate. The questions were technically appropriate, the production plans detailed and specific."
"This goes deeper than we thought," Andy said quietly, his calm voice centering our increasingly circular speculation. "Someone has constructed an elaborate scenario involving all of us, not just Nadia."
"Why?" Nadia asked, the simple question cutting through mounting theories. "What possible reason could anyone have for this level of manipulation?"
We exchanged uncertain glances, no clear answer emerging. The comfortable assumptions that had defined our lives suddenly seemed built on shifting sand. If Ryan's Hamilton opportunity was constructed fiction, what else might be?
"I'm going to the meeting tomorrow," Nadia decided, her expression set with determination. "It's the only way to get answers."
"Absolutely not," Ryan objected immediately. "It's too dangerous."
"Not alone," Braden qualified, surprising us. "But I agree the meeting should happen. It's our best chance to identify who's behind this."
"We'll establish surveillance," Andy suggested pragmatically. "Multiple observation points, emergency protocols, immediate intervention capabilities."
"I'll be wired," Nadia added. "You'll hear everything, be able to communicate with me through an earpiece."
"I still don't like it," Ryan insisted, protective instincts clearly engaged.
"I don't recall asking permission," Nadia replied with unusual sharpness. Then, softening, she touched his arm gently. "I appreciate your concern. But this involves my career, my future. I need to face it directly."
The exchange illuminated an aspect of their relationship I hadn't fully appreciated before—the tension between Ryan's protective impulses and Nadia's independence. Each valued the other's strength while sometimes misinterpreting its expression.
"We'll be right there," I reassured them both, theatrical problem-solving engaged. "Lincoln Center has multiple vantage points, plenty of public presence. It's actually an excellent choice for a controlled confrontation."
As we constructed a detailed plan for the meeting, I found my attention repeatedly drawn to Nadia. Throughout this unexpected development, she had maintained remarkable composure. The initial shock had transformed into strategic thinking, vulnerability into strength.
Whatever waited at Lincoln Center tomorrow, I found myself surprisingly confident in our collective ability to handle it—not because we had all the answers, but because we had each other. Our unconventional arrangement had created unconventional strengths, connections that transcended traditional definitions.
Three days until the London audition. Two days until we confronted our mysterious observer. One household united despite external attempts to divide us.
The odds, I decided with theatrical optimism, remained decidedly in our favor.