Chapter Fifty-Five (Amaya)

“What are you doing?” I asked when I heard Sin behind me.

“Can I join you?” He asked with a smile as he reached for the button on his jeans.

My heart raced as I watched him undress.

“I’m assuming that since you didn’t answer that it was a yes.” He chuckled as he stepped into the shower with me.

“You are a sneaky demon.” I smiled as he placed his hands on my shoulders, his eyes swirling red, orange, and yellow, as he leaned down and kissed me. His hands ran down my arms, sending shivers up my spine.

I placed my hands on his muscular chest and pushed him away. “I came in here to shower.” Smirking, I scolded him, trying not to show how aroused I really was.

He quirked a brow at me, grabbing the soap from behind me and lathering it into a loofah. “Then let me wash you.”

“Really, you are such a brat.” I laughed as he walked behind me and washed my back and ass.

He reached around to my front to wash my breasts and stomach as he kissed and nipped my neck. A moan escaped my lips as he dropped the loofah and massaged my breasts, gently pinching and pulling on my nipples, making heat rise in my core.

I turned to face him and he cupped my ass with his hands as I wrapped my arms around his neck and kissed him, my core heating at his touch. I opened my mouth and invited him in as he our kiss deepened. He lifted me by the waist, and I wrapped my legs around his midsection as he walked from the shower to the bedroom. Without releasing me, he sat on the bed, so I was straddling him.  

His length pressed against my sex as we continued to kiss and explore each other’s bodies.

Sin growled as he flipped me onto my back, leaning over me. His eyes swirling so fast it was dizzying, his hands trailed down my front, exploring and caressing my body as he travelled lower. Finding the sensitive bud, he pinched it and played with it. I looked up at him as he slid his finger into my sex, slowly moving it in and out, involuntarily moaning. He quieted my moan with his kiss as he worked two more fingers into my sex; he pulled away from me and smiled.

“Like that little flame?” he smirked.

I glared at him and pushed him onto his back. His smile deepened as I climbed on top of him, kissing his chest and working my way down towards his shaft, stopping just before I reached it.

“Damn, come on,” he cursed as I worked my way back up to his mouth.

“You tease me, and I’ll tease you.” I chuckled as I grabbed his length with my hand, working it up and down, massaging my thumb over the sensitive tip as he bucked into my hand.

I wanted so badly to have him inside me, releasing him, I looked at him suddenly nervous.

“If you want me, I am yours, Amaya.” Sin whispered, brushing my hair from my cheek.

I touched his cheek and leaned down to him, kissing him as I positioned his length with my entrance. Slowly, I worked it inside me as I felt him fill me. He was big and his size was uncomfortable, Sin moaned as his hands went to my waist and pulled me down on him, I gasped in response as tears stung my eyes. I froze, feeling the fullness inside me.

Sin sat up in alarm. “Are you okay, I didn’t mean to hurt you.”

“You didn’t,” I smiled, “Just wasn’t expecting you to be so big.”

He smiled, leaning up to kiss me, his hands staying on my hips.

Once I got used to his size, I slowly moved on his length, increasing the pace as he moved helped me move on top of him, my breath hitched as I reached orgasm.

Sin smiled up at me, flipping me onto my back as he worked himself in and out of my body, kissing and nipping at my skin as he did. Letting out a moan as he increased his pace and he let out a growl as he came inside me as I reached my second orgasm. He slowed the pace but did not remove himself from me, I could feel his member pulsing inside me. He rested his forehead against mine, catching his breath.

 He kissed me again as he removed himself and pulled me to him, cuddling him.

I rested my head on his shoulder as I listened to his heartbeat slow. He massaged my shoulder with the arm he had under me, lulling me to sleep.

I woke up a while later cold and pulled the blankets over me, Sin was awake watching me.

“What?” I asked, half asleep.

“Just watching you sleep.”

“That’s not creepy at all.” I muttered.

“Yeah, I guess it’s a little odd,” he laughed.

“Why aren’t you sleeping?”

“Are you this close with Lazarus?”

“What?” I asked, annoyed, suddenly wide awake, I sat up and looking at him. “If I recall properly, you made that deal with him, not me? “

He frowned, “So you have been.”

“I didn’t say that. But so, what if I was?” I asked, suddenly feeling guilty about what had happened.

“Would you want to?”

“Sin, I have told both of you I am attracted to both of you, so yes, I suppose I would. I would like to remind you I did not make the deal you did.” Pissed off, I stood up. I added, “and neither of you took into consideration that I might end up deepening those feelings for both of you while this bet of yours took place, did you?”

“If you were asked today, who would you choose?” Sin asked, suddenly standing in front of me.

I couldn’t meet his gaze, “I don’t know.” I answered honestly. “Because I love you both.” I added, fighting the tears that threatened to fall.

“If you had no choice but to choose one, which one would you choose?” He asked again, His eyes swirling and seeming to beg me for an answer.

I looked at him as tears fell against my will.

“I said I don’t know.” I yelled at him as I turned to leave, but he grabbed my arm.

“I’m sorry, I didn’t realize that when we made the bet, it would only complicate matters.”

“Well, it did. I am going to shower… Alone.” I snapped before I turned and went to the bathroom.

I emerged a few minutes later, clean and dressed, to find Sin asleep on the couch.

It was the middle of the night, and yet I was wide awake. Cana flew in the window and landed in front of me.

“I have news.” She said, out of breath.

“What’s wrong?” I asked her.

“I was spying in the library, thought it would be a good idea to follow Lazarus.”

“Why would you spy on him, I trust him?”

“The vial of blood I saw it controls him. He was trying to find a way around it and a way to kill Hellebore. She showed up and forbade him from telling anyone, especially you, and ordered that he kill Abigail, or he would die in her place.”