Chapter 41
Josh’s POV
I had to think over Tucker’s question. The chemistry between all of us is electrifying and my first instinct is to say yes. Tucker gave us both towels so that we could clean up while I was thinking.
What is this feeling I have with Tucker? When did it start? It scared the hell out of me.
I looked into Cyn’s beautiful green eyes, hope flashed in her eyes as I leaned down to give her a kiss. Our mouths moved together slowly as I savored her taste.
“I love you,” I whispered in her ear.
“I love you, too,” she whispered with a gentle smile. A bright grin makes it’s way onto my face as I cupped her cheek and pressed another kiss to her plump lips.
“We don’t have to do anything, right?” I asked Cyn while pointing at Tucker. Even though there’s a strange heat between us doesn’t mean we need to act on it. For Christ’s sake, I’m not gay.
“We can discuss boundaries for everyone so that nobody feels uncomfortable in this relationship.” Tucker chipped in.
Okay, boundaries are promising. Can I bear to share her though? For fuck’s sake, she’s my soulmate! It feels unfair that I must share her with someone else. However, I know she’ll never give up Tucker. There’s too much love and sacrifice in that relationship. I don’t want to have to watch them grow old together while I remain by myself.
“I’ll give it a try.” I answered them. Cyn beamed up at me in happiness, making me feel good about my decision.
“So who is the boyfriend and who is the side chick?” I asked.
Cyn looked at me in confusion, “you’re both my boyfriends. I refuse to hide someone like we’re doing something shameful.”
I was impressed with her fire and insistence that no one is hidden.
“So round two?” I asked the two of them. Cyn laughed and hit my shoulder while Tucker just grinned.
The next morning, I woke up with an ass pressed against my dick. I rubbed myself against the softness and enjoyed the feeling of it rubbing me in return.
I slung my hand around Cyn’s waist and began to squeeze her tits.
“Mmmm….” She moaned gently. I snaked my other arm around her and slid it down into her panties, feeling her wetness while she sleeps.
I rubbed her pretty clit in circles until she creamed all over my fingers in her sleep.
Feeling a bit impatient now that I have an all access pass to my girl, I pull my boxers off and slide her panties and tank top off.
I’m in heaven as I screw my fat cock into her tiny pussy. My woman remains sleeping while Tucker is snoring away. I continue my hard thrusts into Cyn, watching her tits bounce with each pump of my hips.
Cyn has a kink where she wants to get screwed while she sleeps. Tucker let me know so I decided to give it a shot. It’s incredibly arousing to take her body any way I want and she can’t do anything about it.
A few more thrusts and I shoot my seed deep into her hot cunt. I rub the leaking cum all over her clit, wanting to rub out another orgasm for her before I get ready for the day.
My cum lubricated my fingers as I rubbed back and forth until finally her sweet pussy exploded all over the place.
I rolled over and breathed heavily into the room. That was awesome.
I decided to take a shower and get dressed for school. I looked at Cyn and Tucker still sleeping on the bed. The covers were disheveled and I could see her leaking pussy from where I laid. Damn, that was hot.
I wasn’t too keen on sharing her but the more I thought about it, the hotter it started to seem.
Soon I was out of the shower and I woke the two sleepy heads up.
“I don’t want to get out of bed.” Cyn whined.
I couldn’t help but chuckle at her antics. She loves the bed way too much.
“Did someone play with me?” She asked sleepily.
“I did, baby,” I murmured in her ear as I lick her neck.
“That’s so hot,” she groaned as she fingered her juicy pussy, probably feeling all my cum leaking.
“Is that okay?” I asked her.
“That’s more than okay, it’s my favorite fantasy after all.” She answered with a coy smile.
Tucker snorted himself awake and then the two of them started getting ready for school.
When we were all done, we went out front and took my car to school.
Pulling in, I noticed the usual students staring, there are a few more guys looking than normal but I’m sure it’s because Cyn is with us. Both of us.
I grabbed her left hand while Tucker grabbed her right and I heard someone literally gasp. The three of us moved like one unit to Cyn’s locker.
“Whoa. You have some explaining to do ma’am.” Helena said to Cyn as soon as she saw the three of us.
“I know, I know. I’ll tell you soon, promise.”
Tucker pulled Cyn towards him and pressed his plump lips to hers. She sucked on his bottom lip, making him groan right in the middle of the hallway. As quick as it started, they stopped messing around and Tucker left to go to his class.
I held Cyn’s hand as I walked with her to our first class. A smug smile made it’s way on my face when we passed by an irate Alex. He stood staring at our intertwined fingers with rage clear in his eyes.
I’ve been toying with an idea of something to do to Alex to get him to leave her alone. The only problem is I don’t know how effective it would be.
At lunchtime we sat with Helena and Matty while Cyn explained that we were both her boyfriends. She squealed a bit which seemed to surprise Matty.
“So Helena, when are you going to get with someone?” Cyn asked, catching Helena off guard.
“Well, it’s not like I’m popular with men. I’m not going to find one man, let alone two like some people.” She teased.
“If popularity were based on personality, you’d be the most popular girl in school.” Matty chimed in. Wow, look at him trying to flirt. It’s awkward, though kind of cute. I guess. I don’t know the dude too well, he’s Tucker’s best friend, not mine.
Helena’s lip twitched like she was trying to hold back a laugh. “Thank you, Matt.”
He blushed a little, being obvious with his crush. The only person who couldn’t see it was Helena. I don’t know what her opinion of Matty is but I think he’d be good to her. He seems the type to treat a woman well.
The rest of the school day passed by fairly quickly.
“Can I have Cyn to myself the rest of the day? Or does that go against someone’s boundary?” I asked Cyn and Tucker as we walked out of the school.
“I don’t mind,” Tucker said with an easy smile.
“Of course, Josh. Whatever you need to feel secure in this relationship.” Cyn smiled.
She walked over to Tucker and pressed her body against his, making my dick twitch in my pants. He leaned down to capture her lips and they made out heatedly for a few minutes before parting. Tucker winked at me and then took off, probably to try and hitch a ride with Matt.
“How do you feel about being watched during sex?’ I asked her. She seemed startled that I even asked the question.
“I mean, I’m not entirely sure. I would be willing to try.” She said. Fuck yes, that’s all I need, is her to be willing. If she doesn’t like it, we can stop and not revisit the topic.
“You see, my brother has been a royal pain in my ass. I’ve seen how he looks at you. I can find no better revenge than fucking you in front of him. For him to be so close but not be able to feel you grip his cock with your pussy or swallow him whole. It’ll drive him mad.”
“Do you want to do it?” She asked me. I nod, answering honestly.
“Then we can try it. I’ll tell you if I want to stop. Okay?” She said.
“Of course, baby.” I grabbed her hand and led her into the house and straight to Garrett’s room.
I entered without knocking, making him roll his eyes at me.
“What’s this?” He asked.
I grinned at him, catching his attention. “Do you want to watch us fuck?”