Surprise!

After making love with Gerry several more times, we lay on the bed cuddling under the blankets, finally having made it back onto it. I was surprised that he hadn’t taken long to recharge after cumming. I thought it would take him at least half an hour or so, but no. It was usually minutes, while other times he hadn’t even been able to pull out of me before he started over again. I was so sore that I wasn’t sure if I could even move. He kissed my shoulder.
“Annie?”
“Yeah, Gerry?”
“Are you going to leave now that we’ve had our night?” He asked quietly.
I tensed as I tried to figure out why he was asking. I pulled back away from him.
“Do you want me to leave?” I asked sadly.
He rolled toward me to study my face before sighing. “No, Annie. Now that I’ve had you, I want you to stay with me, but if you want to go… I swear, I will try to let you go.”
I sighed before running my fingers through his hair. “Our parents sent me here to scout for an apartment. I got accepted into the vet tech program at the Grimm Forest Animal Shelter. It’s a really cool program. If I excel in the program, I have a good chance of being chosen as the student to be sent to their college for free to become a veterinarian. Can you just see it? Dr. Annaria May Parker, D.V.M.” I gushed, waving my hands in the air as I imagined my name on a billboard.
“So that’s why you came…”
I smiled widely at him. “I could have stayed home and gone straight for my license. You know, Daddy would have gladly paid for my education. There were also a couple other dozen programs like this across the country. I could have gone to any of them.”
“Why didn’t you?” He asked.
“Because I didn’t apply anywhere else. Besides, you’re at Grimm Forest. I thought it would be best if we talked away from our family,” I told him, blushing.
“Yeah, ‘cuz talking worked so well,” he said.
I nuzzled into his throat. “It did enough.”
He held me for a moment before sighing. “You were always my Kryponite, Annie. This just made it worse.”
“Good. I was thinking that we should get an apartment together.”
His eyes widened. “What?”
“I want you to live with me. We can be free here together,” I told him.
“Fuck, Annie! What am I going to do with you?”
“Everything, I hope,” I answered shyly.
He groaned. “What are we going to tell our family?”
I shrugged. “Tell them we made up and that I called you because I was scared.”
“You have really thought about this a lot, haven’t you?”
“Every day since you left.”
“If I move in with you, then we are in a relationship.”
“A relationship?” I repeated, shocked.
“Yes, a relationship. I want to take you out on dates, come home to you, love you freely, and fuck you whenever I want. A relationship,” he said.
“But everyone knows we’re related.”
He covered my mouth. “Stop fucking saying that. It’s what I want in return if I move in with you.”
I stared at him for a moment before nodding timidly. “Okay, but I want something, too.”
“What do you want, Annie?” He asked.
“I’ll tell you later, but when I do, you can’t tell me no.”
“As long as it's not telling our family that we’re involved, I will agree. They would kill me.”
I pecked his lips. “It’s not.” I settled down beside him, running my fingers over his chest. “Why were you at the bar?”
He stiffened before sitting up on the edge of the bed, facing away from me. “I was out with Corey.”
I sat up, pulling the blankets with me to keep my breasts covered, so I could run my hands up his back to his shoulders. I nuzzled into his neck.
“It’s okay if you were looking for a girl. I understand. I was a being a brat and-”
He pulled me around so that I was on his lap. “I missed you, Annie. All those other girls meant nothing to me. I was trying to forget you.”
I wrapped my arms around his neck. “It’s okay. I promise you. How many were there?”
“Annie,” he groaned.
“How many, Gerry?” I repeated.
“I don’t know. I had a different one every other night. Multiplied by three years. Some nights I had two or three girls… My guess is about 600.”
I stared at him in shock. “600?”
He sighed. “Yes. They weren’t you, Annie. You’re hard to forget. Impossible even.”
I leaned my forehead against his. “Okay. I understand.”
“I never had unprotected sex before you,” he said softly.
“Okay. I believe you.” I kissed him softly. “Now that’s handled, we need to go get the morning after pill.”
“Yeah. We do. But hold on for a minute. I just want to hold you for a second.”
Fifteen minutes later, we were dressed and in the car, heading to the pharmacy down the road with him holding my hand. I eyed him curiously.
“How did your car get here? I thought Corey drove us to the inn.”
“Corey brought it. I linked him while we were getting ready.”
“Oh.”
I turned my head to study the face that was so deeply ingrained in my memories that I could paint it from memory. That was, if I had the talent to paint or draw. I sighed, and he lifted our joined hands to kiss the back of mine. If someone had told me 24 hours ago that I would be sitting here next to Gerry after giving him my virginity, I would have told them that they were liars. When he pulled up in front of the pharmacy, I glanced at the store. The big neon red lights of the Walgreens almost glared daggers at me.
“Do you want me to go in with you, Bannannie?” He asked softly.
“No. It’s okay.”
I climbed out of the car and went back to the pharmacy counter. The elderly pharmacy tech behind the counter smiled at me.
“Picking up or dropping off, dear?” She asked.
“Ummm… neither. I need the morning after pill,” I answered, looking down at the floor while I shifted nervously.
“What’s your name?”
“Annaria Parker? But I don’t understand why you need to know my name.”
She quickly flipped through a stack of papers before shaking her head. “I’m sorry, ma’am, but I cannot supply you with Plan B without your parents' consent. You get that and come back; I will give it to you.”
“My mother said I could have it.” I immediately lied.
“Perfect. I need to hear it from her. If you would, please call her.”
I stared at her in shock. “But she said I could.”
“Then you won’t have any trouble calling her,” she told me.
I threw my hands up in frustration before turning around and leaving. I got back in Gerry’s car, slamming the door behind me.
“Did you get it?” He asked.
“No. They said they couldn’t without Mom’s permission,” I informed him, bursting into tears.
“WHAT?! WHY?!”
“I don’t know,” I sobbed as I buried my face in my hands.
“I’ll be right back,” he growled before getting out of the car.
I watched him walk confidently inside the store before coming back out a few minutes later with a bag. When he got back in the car, tossing the bag onto my lap, my eyes widened as boxes of Plan B fell out of it. I stared at him as he backed out.
“How did you get this?” I asked.
He shrugged, Kraven flashing in his eyes. “It doesn’t matter. I got it. Let’s go eat. I’m starving.”
I remained quiet while he drove to Denny’s. It was my favorite place to eat because no one judged me for eating breakfast any time I walked in, no matter what time it was. We walked in, got a table, and before the waitress could hand us menus, he smiled at her.
“I’ll take the Slamburger with a coffee. Black. And she will take the Moon Over My Hammy breakfast with sauteed mushrooms, onions, and cheese in the hashbrowns. She will also take a strawberry shake with extra cool whip, no sprinkles, and two cherries on top. Thank you.”
When she walked away, I smiled at him. “You remembered.”
“Yes, baby, I did. I remember everything about you.”
I felt my cheeks heat up before glancing around, making him chuckle.
“Nobody is paying us any mind, beautiful. This is a human restaurant. They don’t know who we are.”
“But what if there are shifters?”
“There’s not. Relax,” he told me.
“Alright. I’ll try.”
Over the next two hours, we talked about everything from his classes to my program. It was nice to be back with him. I really had missed him. Every time he laughed, my heart beat faster, and every time he looked at me, I melted more. After we were done eating, we went back to the hotel. As soon as he stepped inside the room, he began to get undressed, and I let out a small squeal as I covered my face.
“What?”
“You’re getting naked,” I mumbled.
“We had sex, Annie. You’ve already seen me naked,” he chuckled.
“It’s different…” I muttered.
“So, I take it that’s a no to showering together?”
“GERRY!”
He chuckled again. “Fine. I’ll shower when I go home to get clothes.”
“To get clothes?” I squeaked.
“Yes. I’m coming back. You’re mine, remember?”
I flushed darkly. “Okay.”
He pulled my hands down to peck my lips. “You have an hour, Annie. Shower because when I get back, you and I are going to work on this nudity issue that you’re having.”
He pocketed the key card before walking out of the room, whistling to himself, leaving me standing frozen in the middle of the room.
‘One hour, Annie,’ he linked.
I jumped into action, scrambling to shower before he got back. As I wrapped the towel around me, someone knocked on my door. I rushed to pull it open, smiling before it was wiped off my face. Standing in front of me were five scantily clad people that made my heart race furiously.
“Mom? Dads?”
My mother crossed her arms over her chest as she studied my face. “Hello, Annaria. Are you going to invite us in, or are you going to explain to us, along with everyone else that can hear us, why you want the morning after pill?”