Chapter 09 Strong Medicine
So, the books I picked out for Katniss were your run-of-the-mill steamy couple stuff. No way was I gonna throw any cuckoldry her way—didn't want to risk her getting any wild ideas. Even though I trust her, I wasn't about to roll those dice. I held off on the father-in-law and daughter-in-law smut too; figured she needed to ease into it. Every day at work, I’d carve out some time to sift through adult novels, and man, it was a brain-buster. But hey, it paid off. From the videos, I could see Katniss getting more and more hooked on the spicy reads, and she was getting pretty wild during her solo sessions at night. I knew it was time to up the ante.
Since Katniss was already digging the adult lit, I decided to drop a father-in-law and daughter-in-law story on her. This was my first shot at seeing how she'd react to that kind of taboo. But I had to be careful—not too hardcore right off the bat. If her first taste of this stuff was too much, it could blow up the whole plan. Setting up the regular smut was already a headache, and now diving into the father-in-law and daughter-in-law stuff was a whole new level of stress. I spent over half a month prepping before I started slipping those stories into the mix. When I finally had them all lined up, I let out a big sigh of relief. After all the vanilla stuff, it was time to spice things up. I was dying to see how she'd react to these forbidden tales. Would she be into it like I was?
That night, I snuck the first father-in-law and daughter-in-law story onto the computer, itching to see her reaction on the video the next day. Her response was crucial for my plan. The first story was a real-life account from a women's site, about wives who, with their husbands away, couldn't resist the temptation and ended up with their father-in-laws. No explicit scenes, just a real-life drama. It seemed like the perfect starting point.
After setting it up, I got all jittery, super anxious about how Katniss would take it. If she was grossed out, the whole plan could tank. The next day at work was torture, and I rushed home as soon as I could. Everything seemed normal, but Katniss had this weird vibe, like a touch of sadness in her eyes. I couldn't wait to check the video to see if my story had anything to do with it. During dinner, I noticed her giving Nathan these odd looks, but I couldn't quite figure out what was up.
After dinner, Katniss was lounging on the bed while I pretended to work on some reports at the computer. My mind was racing, imagining her reaction to the story, and I kept sneaking glances at her. I was so distracted, I kept screwing up the reports. Katniss was fiddling with her phone, shooting me these hesitant looks. Finally, she seemed to make up her mind. "Hey babe, how you feeling lately? Any better?" she asked, all cautious-like.
"What do you mean, feeling better? What are you talking about?" I played dumb, acting all clueless.
"You know what I mean," Katniss blushed, looking a bit flustered.
"What exactly are you talking about? You're confusing me," I teased her, secretly getting a kick out of it.
"Oh, forget it, I'm not talking to you, you're so annoying," she huffed, putting down her phone and turning away. I quickly climbed onto the bed and wrapped my arms around her. "Hey, babe, don't be mad. I was just messing with you. My health's still not great, my libido's low, and I can't get fully hard. It's frustrating." I couldn't let her know I was getting better; she'd start overthinking everything. Hearing this, she suddenly turned all comforting.
"It's okay, honey, it'll get better one day. Just take care of yourself. I love you," she said, giving me a gentle kiss on the lips.
"I love you too, babe. Get some sleep, okay?" After that, she closed her eyes, but I caught a flicker of disappointment in them.
About half an hour later, she was out cold, snoring softly. I knew she wanted to get it on earlier; her desire had been building up, especially with all the spicy reads I'd been feeding her. Katniss is still pretty shy, so for her to bring up my health like that, her sexual frustration must've been through the roof.
I hopped over to the computer, heart racing, and fired up the video software, dying to see her reaction. In the video, Katniss came home, did her usual tidying up, and then eagerly turned on the computer. When the page I set up popped up, she clicked on it right away. At first, she seemed curious, but as she read, her eyebrows started to knit together. She kept reading, though, moving from curiosity to surprise, and then to shock. Her mouth hung open in disbelief as she finished the father-in-law and daughter-in-law story.
It was probably her first time seeing anything like that. After a moment of shock, she closed her eyes and took a deep breath, trying to calm herself. When she opened her eyes again, she stared at the screen for a bit before closing the webpage, her hand over her chest like she was trying to steady her heart. Yeah, Katniss has always been a good girl, so this kind of stuff must've been a real jolt to her system. After a while, she glanced over at Nathan in the living room, a hint of curiosity in her eyes. That’s when I realized what was different about her look earlier—it was that spark of curiosity.
People are always curious about new things, and Katniss was no different. She checked the time, saw she had a bit before I got home, and then lay on the bed, closing her eyes. I could see her chest rising and falling heavily, not fast, but enough to show she was pretty rattled, trying to calm herself down.
Seeing this, I knew my first father-in-law and daughter-in-law story had really shaken her up, breaking some of her old perceptions and giving her new thoughts. From the curiosity in her eyes when she looked at Nathan during dinner, I knew my plan had a shot. I saw a glimmer of hope in pushing forward, so I decided to load up more of those stories tonight. With my heart pounding in excitement, I set everything up, closed the computer, and lay down on the bed, eagerly anticipating Katniss's reaction the next night.